Cakes
American Cheesecake
$7.00Topped American Cheesecake
Slice $8.95American Cheesecake topped with Strawberry, Cherry, Raspberry, Chocolate, or Nutella.
Italian Cheesecake
$7.95Made with Ricotta & Lemon
Sundaes
Hot Fudge Sundae
$9.50Your favorite Gelato topped with hot fudge, whipped cream, and another topping of your choice.
Morte de Cioccolato (Death by Chocolate)
$10.50Your choice of a slice of our homemade Chocolate Cannoli Cake or Cheese Cake served with our homemade Chocolate Chocolate Chip Gelato, topped with hot fudge and whipped topping.
Oreo Sundae
$9.50Large serving of our Vanilla Gelato topped with hot fudge, Oreos, and whipped topping.
Snickers Volcano
$9.50Large serving of our Snicker Gelato topped with hot fudge, Snickers, and whipped topping.
Peanut Butter Fantasy
$9.50Large serving of our Peanutto Gelato topped with hot fudge, Reese’s, and whipped topping.
Brownie Lover's Sundae
$10.50Baci Ball
$9.50Pizzelle Alla Napolitano
$9.50Our homemade Baci, Strawberry, and Pistachio Gelato sandwiched between warmed Pizzelle Cookies.
Italian Ice Cream Sandwich
$9.50Vaccaro’s Chocolate Devil’s Food Cake layered with our Hazelnut Gelato topped with hot fudge.
Homestyle Pound Cake
$9.502 slices of our warmed homemade pound cake, served with our Vanilla Gelato, topped with strawberries, and whipped topping.
Pastries
Pasticiotti
$3.793 for $11.49Vaccaro’s Style Pie (Individual Serving)
Choice of Vanilla ● Ricotta ● Raspberry Almond
Éclair
$7.30Four of our famous cream puffs drenched with hot fudge and whipped topping
Mini Cream Puff
$1.70Vanilla custard filled. Choice of Plain or Chocolate topped.
Mini Chocolate Topped Puff
$1.99Sfogliatelle
$3.79Crispy pastry filled with baked Ricotta and Citron.
Napoleon
$4.99Layers of filled puffed pastry
Choice of Vanilla ● Chocolate Vanilla ● Raspberry Vanilla ● Coconut Crème ● Apple
Cannoli
An authentic Sicilian favorite, the cannoli is a crispy shell filled with sweet ricotta cream and chocolate chips. Filled to order.
Cannoli
$5.25Chocolate Dipped
$6.50Mini Cannoli
$3.00Chocolate Dipped Mini
$3.50Individual Chips-n-Dip
$5.49
Colosseos ~
Served over Homemade Belgian Waffle (Whole, Half or Quarter).
Santa María
Quarter $8.95 · Half $12.00 · Whole $14.50Baci Gelato topped with hot fudge, wet nuts, and whipped topping
The Original Colosseo
Quarter $8.95 · Half $12.00 · Whole $14.50Vanilla Gelato topped with strawberries, wet nuts, and whipped topping.
Lost at Sea
Quarter $8.95 · Half $12.00 · Whole $14.50Italian Cookies & Cream and Vanilla Chocolate Chip Gelati topped with hot fudge, wet nuts and whipped topping.
Niña
Quarter $8.95 · Half $12.00 · Whole $14.50Peanutto Gelato topped with hot fudge and whipped topping.
Gelato
Gelato
Reg $6.95 · Reg $7.95Waffle Cone + $1.25Waffle Bowl + $1.25Italian Cookies and Cream ~ Snickers ~ Vanilla ~ Holy Cannoli ~ Chocolate Chocolate Chip ~ Baci ~ Chocolate ~ S’more’s ~ Vanilla Chocolate Chip ~ Amaretto ~ Strawberry ~ Almond Joy ~ Mint Chocolate Chip ~ Pistachio ~ Nocciola ~ Donkey Tracks ~ Peanutto & Fudge ~ Caffe ~ Banana Choc Chip (seasonal) ~ Peppermint Pattie (seasonal)
Cone add $1.29
Granita
Regular $6.50Small $5.50Choice of Granita, served with two sugar cookies
Lemon ~ Raspberry ~ Strawberry ~ Mango ~ Chocolate ~ Watermelon
Gelato Flights
$9.50Choice of four flavors (toppings not available for this item)
Toppings
$2.25Waffle Cones add $1.50Waffle Bowl (when available) add $1.50Hot Fudge ~ Caramel Sauce ~ Chocolate Sauce ~ Chocolate Chips ~ Wet Nuts ~ Strawberries ~ Reese’s ~ Oreos ~ Snickers
Toppings (Free)
Whipped Topping ~ Chocolate Jimmies ~ Sliced Almonds ~ Maraschino Cherries
Gelato
Pint $7.80 · Quart $14.25Italian Cookies and Cream ~ Snickers ~ Vanilla ~ Holy Cannoli ~ Chocolate Chocolate Chip ~ Baci ~ Chocolate ~ S’more’s ~ Vanilla Chocolate Chip ~ Amaretto ~ Strawberry ~ Almond Joy ~ Mint Chocolate Chip ~ Pistachio ~ Nocciola ~ Donkey Tracks ~ Peanutto & Fudge ~ Caffe ~ Banana Choc Chip (seasonal) ~ Peppermint Pattie (seasonal)
Granita
Granita
Reg $3.99 · Med $4.99 · Lg $5.99Limone (Lemon) ~ Fragola (Strawberry) ~ Raspberry ~ Mango (seasonal) ~ Watermelon (seasonal)
Granita
Pint $7.35 · Quart $11.40Limone (Lemon) ~ Fragola (Strawberry) ~ Raspberry ~ Mango (seasonal) ~ Watermelon (seasonal)
Cookie Assortment
We make over 30 varieties of Italian cookies and biscotti. Customer favorites include Sliced Almond, Pignoli, Amaretti, and Red Cherry Macaroons.
Assorted cookies $22.95 / lb.
Filled Butter Sandwich
Five Assorted $8.50Chocolate ~ Raspberry ~ Strawberry ~ Nutella
Our Famous Italian Macaroons
$2.75Three Assorted $6.50Five Assorted $8.50Pignoli ~ Sliced Almond ~ Amaretti ~ Red Cherry
Italian Biscotti
$2.75Three Assorted $6.50Five Assorted $8.50Cranberry Walnut ~ Pistachio ~ Chocolate Cherry ~ Vanilla ~ Chocolate Dipped ~ Cinnamon ~ Sugar Free Vanilla
Vaccaro's Italian Cookies
$2.75Three Assorted $6.50Five Assorted $8.50Rainbow ~ Salted Caramel ~ Zoe's Cannoli Cookie ~ Ricotta Cookie ~ Lemon Drop ~ Lemon Iced
Chocolate Swirl Shortbread ~ Italian Strudel ~ Chocolate Granola ~ Walnut Raisin ~ Anise Iced ~ Wedding Cookie
Italian Coconut ~ Old Fashion ~ Francy ~ Sweetheart ~ Vaccaro's Sugar ~ Ribbon Cookie (October only)
Crunchy Chocolate Almond
$5.99/bagFour of our famous cream puffs drenched with hot fudge and whipped topping
Doggie Biscotti
$5.00/bagFour of our famous cream puffs drenched with hot fudge and whipped topping
Desserts
x